Hubler For Business Families
  • Home
  • About
    • Tom Hubler
    • News & Press
  • Services
    • Succession Planning
    • Ownership Planning
    • Management and Leadership Planning
    • Business Planning
    • Family Planning
    • Family Renewal Retreat
  • Speaking
  • Book
  • Resources
    • Free Assessment
    • Case Studies
    • Vision for Success
    • Blog
  • Contact
  • Home
  • About
    • Tom Hubler
    • News & Press
  • Services
    • Succession Planning
    • Ownership Planning
    • Management and Leadership Planning
    • Business Planning
    • Family Planning
    • Family Renewal Retreat
  • Speaking
  • Book
  • Resources
    • Free Assessment
    • Case Studies
    • Vision for Success
    • Blog
  • Contact

Intellectual Property and Succession Planning

6/20/2016

76 Comments

 
Return on Your Investment: Securing Family and Business Assets

Key Takeaways:
  • Many IP ownership issues can be minimized by setting clear ground rules or expectations right when the business begins.
  • When IP is involved, family-owned business clients should understand and record their plans for future ownership, licensing and/or sale of patents.
  • Regular family meetings will help to uncover and resolve emotional issues that can strain even the closest of families and their business.

Many conflicts can erode family relationships in a family-owned business - succession, ownership, estate management, leadership, retirement, perceived fairness and more. But one of the most unique and damaging can be the disagreement over intellectual property. The title of this article - "Intellectual Property and Succession Planning" -describes what would seem to be a straightforward process. But those two word pairs can hide a maze of misunderstanding, confusion and heartache.

Intellectual property can mark a point at which the family, the business, entrepreneurialism, patents and copyrights may overlap so much that no one clearly recognizes boundaries, sensitivities or direction. Past and future collide in a fight for the fuzzy present. I have seen it create havoc in personal relationships, tear apart family bonds and destroy business possibilities. It can devastate a loving family and its thriving business.

Take a moment to read this true story. The names and situations were changed to protect the family.

Real-life case study
When I became involved as a family business consultant, an uncle (Joe) and his nephew (Bruce) were in the middle of a dreadful succession planning ordeal. The typical business-family issues of ownership, estate and leadership were compounded by a painful history and intellectual property concerns.

The painful history began 30 years earlier when Bruce was 10 years old. Both of Bruce's parents (Joe's brother and sister-in-law) were killed in an airplane crash. At the time of the tragedy, Joe had left the family's construction business and started one of his own, eventually bringing in his two sons, Bruce's cousins. (I know this is complicated, feel free to read that sentence again!).

With both parents deceased, Uncle Joe invited 10-year-old Bruce into his family. Everyone did their best to make Bruce feel welcome and part of the family, as all three boys were about the same age.

Joe's two sons attended college and returned to join their father's business. Bruce also graduated from college and went his own way, working at various marketing positions and exploring his interests. After several years he moved back to his hometown.

During that time, tensions rose between Joe and his two biological sons over their construction company. Their working relationship had deteriorated over differences about workload, roles, responsibilities and decision-making.

Uncle Joe, an engineer, had also created an invention. He had consulted an attorney and obtained patent protection for his idea. He could see the potential source of revenue and did his best to protect his patent and revenue stream, but had done very little else with his idea. It was essentially only potential, although Joe had ideas and future plans for this separate company.

Tensions grew within Joe's construction company. His two talented sons finally said either he would leave the family business or they would. Reluctantly, Uncle Joe left. He was phased out of his own construction business.

Having come back home, Bruce became interested in his Uncle Joe's patented invention and began collaborating with him on it. Bruce conducted marketing surveys, attended trade shows and determined that there was an opportunity for a viable business selling the invention. Initially, Bruce and Uncle Joe got along well, but as this separate business grew, Bruce wanted more control. Bruce pressured his uncle for a succession plan that would give him future controlling interest in the company and, in the meantime, allow him to continue to make major leadership decisions.

Uncle Joe was in his early 70s but balked at creating a succession plan. He was not ready to retire. Bruce realized that if he grew the company, it would be more expensive for him to buy it. Plus, Uncle Joe owned the patent that was the basis of the company's success. This was the state of the dreadful succession planning ordeal that I was brought in to fix.

Getting succession planning back on track
I talked with Joe and his nephew, Bruce. I interviewed family members who were engaged in but not part of their construction business. I came to recognize that neither Uncle Joe nor Bruce were good communicators. Each could not respect the other's perspective. Uncle Joe did not understand Bruce's concern about the expense of buying the company and controlling his own destiny. Bruce could not appreciate Uncle Joe's need for security, protection of the patent and feeling relevant in the company.

Despite the help of their professional advisor and their own best efforts, Uncle Joe and Bruce were deadlocked. No formal agreements existed between them. Unfortunately, this is not unusual in many family businesses. Written agreements and a formal structure are commonly ignored by relatives who are in business together "because we love each other." In fact, formalities such as this may be viewed with mistrust. Merely bringing them up can trigger hurt feelings.

Unresolved emotional issues added to the complexity between Uncle Joe and his nephew, Bruce, as they tried to resolve patent and succession issues. Bruce had never expressed his own hurt feelings over how his parents' property and family heirlooms were dispersed at the time of their death; he was 10 and Uncle Joe and his family never consulted him about their "family treasures."

Uncle Joe, on the other hand, felt unappreciated for taking Bruce into his family. The hurts were deep and unspoken on both sides.

Solution
To begin the healing, I suggested an intervention I call a Family Forgiveness Ritual©. The entire family participated, including Uncle Joe and his wife, his adult children and their spouses, and Bruce and his spouse. The emotional relief for the family was spectacular. The entire family joined together to create a new beginning. The Family Forgiveness Ritual© opened the emotional door and established an openness and positive foundation for productive business discussions.

Working together with love and respect for each other, the family resolved their business issues - regarding ownership, leadership and the patent. But it took time and many meetings. Uncle Joe eventually sold his share of the business to Bruce. Uncle Joe retains patent ownership until his death, and then the patent transfers to Bruce.

The family learned the hard lessons:
  • Many, if not most, technical issues can be minimized by setting clear ground rules or expectations when the business is begun.
  • Understand and record the plan for future ownership or potential licensing and/or future sale of a patent.
  • Conduct regular family meetings to uncover, discuss and relieve emotional issues that can provoke the best of families and their business.
In these areas and more, professional advisors can offer guidance and leadership to help a business family avoid the maze of intellectual property that is often emotionally charged as well as technically complex.

Conclusion
Intellectual property law firms and professional services can help you:
  • Determine the patentability of an invention
  • Prepare, file and prosecute patent applications in the U.S. and internationally
  • Investigate, defend and prosecute claims of infringement
  • Enforce patent rights through litigation or alternative dispute resolution (ADR)
  • License, police and manage patent portfolios
  • Oversee the acquisition and sale of patented technology

If you enjoyed this article please consider leaving a comment below, sharing it and/or subscribing to have future articles delivered to your RSS feed reader.
76 Comments
Lyn Kim link
8/26/2021 04:05:08 am

Great article! Thank you for sharing this informative post, and looking forward to the latest one.

Reply
Luke John link
9/17/2021 08:45:57 am

This article explained the topic well/ I have learned a lot. Thanks for writing. Keep up the good work!

Reply
Arnold Miths link
9/18/2022 02:19:21 am

Great article! Thank you for sharing this informative post, and looking forward to the latest one.
If you are looking for General Article and deals just visit white cannon dot com

Reply
Tree Stump Grinding Spokane link
9/21/2022 10:09:43 pm

Because you can be sure you have assets that can produce income for you and your family in the future, protecting your wealth is crucial.

Reply
Commercial Concrete Contractor link
9/21/2022 10:37:05 pm

Succession planning is the process of creating talent to take over for executives, leaders, or other key personnel when they change roles, leave the organization, are fired, retire, or pass away.

Look and check our Commercial Concrete Contractor

Reply
Countertops Spokane link
11/29/2022 09:17:47 pm

A company can manage its intangible assets, such as patents, trade secrets, trademarks, and copyrights, in a way that is consistent with its overall business strategy and objectives with the use of an IP strategy.

Reply
Jessie Holloway link
1/10/2023 02:52:25 pm

Thanks so much for talking about how many issues can be avoided simply by creating a succession plan. My brother owns a business and he's been talking about needing a succession plan. We've been looking into finding an accounting firm that can know what they're doing and can help him through the process.

Reply
Property Management link
1/17/2023 09:54:24 am

nice post. Thank you for posting something like this

Reply
Bathroom Remodeler in Fort Worth link
1/18/2023 03:53:19 am

I read this post your post so nice and very informative post thanks for sharing this post

Reply
Kitchen Renovations link
1/18/2023 06:06:45 am

very interesting, good job and thanks for sharing such a good blog.

Reply
Schedule Free Estimate link
1/18/2023 06:23:20 am

Really nice article and helpful

Reply
Master Bathroom Remodeling Fort Worth link
1/18/2023 06:34:43 am

Thanks for sharing this site bro. fantastic

Reply
rental properties link
1/25/2023 10:43:43 am

I’ve been surfing on the web more than 3 hours today, yet I never found any stunning article like yours.

Reply
Fargo foundation repair link
1/29/2023 06:30:24 pm

Thank you for sharing this, it's really sad to see families divided over this kind of things but it happens quite a lot so it's really great to see articles like this that help prepare family business owners for eventual take overs! I would like to recommend my favorite fooundation repair in fargo nd

Reply
Stamped Concrete Patio Kennewick link
2/20/2023 10:52:55 pm

Awesome and interesting article. Great things you’ve always shared with us. Thanks. Just continue composing this kind of post.

Reply
air quality testing tulsa link
2/21/2023 12:42:46 am

A comprehensive estate plan typically transfers assets such as investments, cash, real estate and personal property upon death.

Reply
Tree Cutting Charlottesville link
2/22/2023 12:45:13 am

You have fantastic composing abilities. I'm so satisfied to locate the very same subject I have actually been seeking. Every person is providing me a great deal of praises today. You're outstanding. As an author, you're so great due to the fact that you're such an excellent author.

Reply
reginacleaningservices.ca/move-in-move-out-cleaning link
3/7/2023 09:23:47 pm

Thanks for the article I really enjoyed some of the points u elaborated!

Reply
Property Management Tampa Bay link
3/8/2023 11:02:26 am

Yes. I view it as additional feedback. If the commenter happens to mention something I talked about or otherwise sounds like they knew what I was reading, I find that to be a good sign I was able to get my message across.

Reply
Pool Removal Joliet IL link
3/22/2023 01:05:49 am

I agree that many conflicts can erode family relationships in a family-owned business - succession and ownership. So it.s important to have a succession planning.

Reply
Saint Petersburg Property Management link
3/28/2023 11:18:21 am

I’ve been surfing on the web more than 3 hours today, yet I never found any stunning article like yours.

Reply
www.albanystumpgrinding.com link
4/12/2023 08:06:03 pm

In many cases, the owner-entrepreneur is the intellectual property of the company.

Reply
concrete wall contractors dallas link
4/14/2023 02:46:21 am

When the family, the business, entrepreneurship, patents, and copyrights intersect to a point where no one can determine where the borders, sensitivities, or direction are, that is when intellectual property can be seen as a marker.

Reply
more about us link
4/15/2023 06:54:09 pm

Trademarks, copyrights, patents, and trade secrets – all examples of intellectual property, an intangible personal property for purposes of estate planning.

Reply
www.saratogamovingcompany.com/ link
4/19/2023 08:06:33 pm

What is the purpose of succession planning?

Reply
http://albanystumpgrinding.com link
4/30/2023 02:03:25 am

Allentown Attorney Jack Gross discusses small business succession planning and assessing what is of value, and intellectual property.

Reply
Port Charlotte Property Management link
5/8/2023 02:44:46 pm

Enjoyed reading the article above , really explains everything in detail

Reply
Book a Vacation link
5/18/2023 01:11:07 pm

The power of comments is super amazing. Let me tell you my little experience.

Reply
https://trinitybsc.com/ link
5/21/2023 07:42:23 pm

Thank you for sharing this article, that provides valuable insights into the intersection of intellectual property and succession planning and highlights the importance of proactive measures to secure family and business assets.

Reply
Alturas Florida Property Management link
5/30/2023 12:54:32 pm

Absolutely great post here. It has a lot of key elements that truly makes it work.

Reply
Anna Maria Property Management link
6/8/2023 11:19:07 am

I appreciate the reply and have taken my notes

Reply
Clearwater Property Management link
6/14/2023 09:21:10 am

I’ve read many articles about blogging, but never one about making effective and valuable comments.

Reply
St Petersburg Property Management link
6/20/2023 09:37:50 am

Thanks! The mental image of you writing down notes while reading makes me smile.

Reply
churches in shawnee link
7/5/2023 09:45:00 pm

I visit your blog routinely and prescribe it to those who needed to upgrade their insight effortlessly. The way of composing is phenomenal and furthermore, the substance is first-rate. Gratitude for that astuteness you give the perusers!<a href="https://chariskingdomchurch.com/">churches in shawnee</a>

Reply
Tampa Property Management link
7/13/2023 11:17:48 am

Such an important blog for all the content writer even for me also I have marked all the important point which are mentioned in the blog.

Reply
Largo Property Management link
7/21/2023 01:54:09 pm

Thanks , this is really very informative and detailed article . Kudos

Reply
sydney conveyancing link
9/8/2023 03:38:18 am

Intellectual property is a special asset since it represents a person's expertise and ideas. Intellectual property is an intangible asset that results directly from effort or trade, as opposed to being just a concept in and of itself. Every estate that owns intellectual property must be handled differently, just as no two people think alike. This sector of estate planning is always changing, especially as intellectual "capital" plays a bigger role in commerce as a whole.

Reply
Contractor in Roanoke link
9/27/2023 06:59:45 pm

MW ProBuild is highly specialized in many types of concrete work. Our professionals install sidewalks, remove old and corroded concrete, pour foundations, repair cracks, and more.

Reply
Hydroseeding link
10/2/2023 11:27:42 pm

Established out of our love of the outdoors and the desire to produce a symbiotic relationship between societies' expansion and the environments they expand into.

Reply
Haul and Junk Removal link
10/3/2023 06:08:37 am

Are piles of unwanted clutter taking up valuable space in your home or office?

Reply
Carpet and Tile Cleaning link
10/5/2023 05:48:47 am

Fresh ‘n Dri Carpet & Tile Cleaning has been providing high-quality cleaning in St. George, UT and the surrounding areas since 2011. Let us show you why Fresh ‘n Dri Carpet & Tile Cleaning is the very best carpet cleaning company for you!

Reply
Home and Office Cleaning link
10/6/2023 06:49:57 am

Your Trusted Partner in Home & Office Cleaning!

Reply
residential window cleaning link
10/6/2023 07:32:52 am

licensed and insured full service residential & commercial professional window cleaning company.

Reply
Concert Security link
10/10/2023 12:14:20 am

The intersection of intellectual property and succession planning in family-owned businesses is a complex and often emotionally charged territory. In many cases, it can become a battleground for misunderstandings and strained relationships. The story of Uncle Joe and his nephew Bruce illustrates how these issues can spiral out of control when not properly addressed.

Uncle Joe's patent invention became a focal point of contention between him and Bruce, leading to a succession planning ordeal that threatened to tear apart both their family bonds and the thriving business they had built together. Their failure to communicate effectively and create formal agreements only exacerbated the situation. This situation is not unique; many family businesses neglect formalities like written agreements, assuming that love alone can hold everything together.

Concert security is paramount to ensure the safety and enjoyment of attendees, involving measures such as bag checks, metal detectors, and a strong presence of trained security personnel. Vigilance and crowd management strategies are crucial to prevent potential security threats and maintain a peaceful atmosphere during live music events.

Reply
www.elevatortechnicians.com link
10/10/2023 12:23:50 pm

Intellectual property plays a crucial role in succession planning. Ensuring the seamless transfer of intellectual property rights is essential for preserving and enhancing the value of a business or estate as it transitions to new ownership. Thoughtful consideration of IP assets in succession planning is a strategic move towards long-term success and legacy preservation.

Reply
Customer Relationship Management link
10/13/2023 07:47:16 am

All-in-one Online Membership Management and CRM Software

Reply
https://www.rockymountainoils.com/collections/wood link
10/18/2023 07:40:46 pm

I completely agree with the sentiments expressed in this article. Intellectual property disputes within a family-owned business can indeed be one of the most complex and emotionally charged issues to navigate. Succession planning, as well as the management of assets and ownership, can all seem relatively straightforward on the surface. However, when you throw intellectual property into the mix, it becomes a whole new ball game.

Wood is a versatile natural material that has been used for centuries in construction, furniture, and various other applications due to its strength and aesthetic appeal. It remains an essential resource for sustainable and eco-friendly building practices today. Check website

Reply
Windows Cleaning link
10/19/2023 09:18:57 pm

Experience the difference of Bob Cleans Windows and let your windows shine like never before.

Reply
Garage Door Repair in Atlanta link
10/23/2023 05:35:11 pm

Expert Garage Door Repair and Installation in Atlanta

Reply
trash hauling services link
10/29/2023 04:35:09 pm

Our residential and commercial trash hauling services are provided at an affordable price that won’t break your budget.

Reply
How to Write A Donation Letter link
11/1/2023 07:49:25 am

Donation letters are powerful tools for fundraising and garnering support for your cause, nonprofit, or organization.

Reply
New Member Onboarding link
11/1/2023 08:02:06 am

Welcoming new members to your organization is a pivotal moment.

Reply
Garage Door Repair in Cartersville link
11/15/2023 07:18:41 am

Get Same Day Garage Door Repair Services in Cartersville, GA.

Reply
Garage Door Repair in Marietta link
11/15/2023 07:30:17 am

Get Same Day Garage Door Repair Services in Marietta GA.

Reply
Garage Door Repair in Powder Springs link
11/15/2023 07:37:09 am

Get Same Day Garage Door Repair Services in Powder Springs GA.

Reply
Garage Door Repair in Smyrna link
11/15/2023 07:40:31 am

Get Same Day Garage Door Repair Services in Smyrna GA.

Reply
Garage Door Repair in Cumming link
11/15/2023 07:46:29 am

Get Same Day Garage Door Repair Services in Cumming GA.

Reply
Garage Door Repair in Alpharetta link
11/23/2023 03:38:35 am

Get Same Day Garage Door Repair Services in Alpharetta GA.

Reply
Garage Door Repair in Milton link
11/23/2023 03:58:29 am

Get Same Day Garage Door Repair Services in Milton GA.

Reply
Garage Door Repair in Roswell link
11/23/2023 04:06:55 am

Get Same Day Garage Door Repair Services in Roswell GA.

Reply
vinyl tile brooklyn link
12/5/2023 12:32:23 am

Welcome to Boro rug and carpet! We are a premier carpet and rug store in Brooklyn. We offer the highest quality carpets and rugs at competitive prices.

Reply
Learn more details link
12/7/2023 10:00:21 pm

Integrating intellectual property into succession planning requires careful consideration of the legal, financial, and strategic aspects to ensure a smooth transition and preservation of these valuable assets for future generations or successors.

Reply
https://dahlcore.com/vip-bodyguards link
12/14/2023 09:18:54 pm

This article hits the nail on the head regarding the potential pitfalls in family-owned businesses. Intellectual property disputes can be particularly thorny, and it's essential to address them early on. Clear ground rules and open communication are key to avoiding misunderstandings and emotional conflicts.

Our VIP bodyguard services in New York City offer unparalleled protection, ensuring the safety and peace of mind of our esteemed clients in the bustling urban environment.

Reply
http://www.brooklynsprayfoampros.com link
12/21/2023 08:07:39 pm

What factors should you take into account when creating an intellectual property strategy for your own company, and why is intellectual property important?

Reply
Industrial Cleaning link
1/19/2024 02:15:03 am

Your Alternative Cleaning Services in Melbourne

Reply
drywall removal link
3/8/2024 09:22:51 pm

Take a moment to read this true story. The names and situations were changed to protect the family.

Reply
web link
4/8/2024 03:43:05 pm

The case study you provided underscores the intricate interplay between family dynamics, business operations, and intellectual property (IP) issues in family-owned enterprises. It highlights the importance of proactive communication, formal agreements, and emotional resolution in navigating such complexities.

Reply
Hana link
8/9/2024 05:48:47 am

Thank you so much for sharing this blog.

Reply
Tempest Hosting link
8/12/2024 09:12:48 pm

This is a powerful and insightful observation.

The intersection of family dynamics and intellectual property within a business is often overlooked. You've highlighted a critical issue that can have far-reaching consequences.

Reply
amicoglobal.com link
10/23/2024 03:24:05 pm

Always enjoy reading your posts, keep it up! Your content is both inspiring and informative. Looking forward to seeing what you come up with next.

Reply
rug/carpet link
11/20/2024 10:00:37 pm

We pride ourselves on providing the highest quality customer service possible.

Reply
Gulf Coast Panama Jack link
1/21/2025 01:07:27 am

You're absolutely right. When those two topics – intellectual property and succession planning – collide in a family business, it can be like a bomb going off. It's not just about who gets the house or the shares of the company anymore. It's about who owns the ideas, the innovations, the very essence of what the business is.

Reply
Chiropractor Naples link
1/24/2025 11:58:45 pm

Wow, I never thought about intellectual property being such a big deal in family businesses. It makes sense though, especially when everyone's got their own ideas and contributions. This article sounds like a must-read for anyone involved in a family company.

Reply
El Paso link
2/8/2025 03:46:40 pm

Intellectual property can mark a point at which the family, the business, entrepreneurialism, patents and copyrights may overlap so much that no one clearly recognizes boundaries, sensitivities or direction.

Reply
Roofing Cincinnati OH link
2/17/2025 05:03:40 pm

Protecting what you've built – both your family's well-being and the business you've poured your heart into – is absolutely crucial. It's not just about the bottom line, it's about securing your legacy. And one area that can be a real minefield, especially in family businesses, is intellectual property.


Reply
Pre owned Rolex cincinnati link
3/20/2025 01:48:57 pm

This really hits home. It's easy to overlook the emotional weight that intellectual property can carry, especially within a family business. We often think of succession in terms of tangible assets, but when you add in the 'secret sauce' of the business – the ideas, the processes, the brand – things get incredibly complex. And you're right, it's not just about the legalities, it's about the perceived fairness and the emotional connection family members have to those intangible assets. It's a recipe for some serious family tension if not handled with immense care and open communication.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Most read blogs

    Categories

    All
    Business Planning
    Case Studies
    Family Planning
    Featured In
    Management And Leadership
    Most Read Articles
    Ownership Planning
    Succession Planning
    Twin Cities Business

    RSS Feed

    FREE Resources

    Family Renewal Retreat™

    SCHEDULE YOUR FREE ORIENTATION MEETING.

    Take this risk-free first step in ensuring the continued success of your family business now. There is no charge for the orientation meeting other than out-of-pocket expenses for travel. 

    TOM HUBLER WILL GIVE YOU A FREE ORIENTATION.

    Does your family business need help with succession planning, conflict resolution, management or other issues? If so, we'll arrange a one-on-one orientation meeting with you and Tom Hubler to help you explore the possibilities of working with us. If you choose, your family and business associates can also attend. Here, in a relaxed environment, you can talk about:
    • Key family business issues
    • Plans necessary for the success of your family-owned business
    • Possibilities and expectations
    • Terms of the relationship

About

Hubler for Business Families helps family businesses manage the boundary between their business/financial concerns and family relationships.

LEARN MORE

Services

Succession Planning
​Management and Leadership Planning
Ownership Planning
Business Planning
Family Planning
Family Renewal Retreat
Speaking

Resources

Picture
Case Studies
​Vision for Success
​Other Resources
Site Map
​The Soul of Family Business

SHOP The Soul Of Family Businesses
Free Assessment
​© COPYRIGHT HUBLER FOR BUSINESS FAMILIES 2022. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
​
WEBSITE DESIGNED BY: SKOL MARKETING